# Allianz vs. AXA: Who Has the Better SEO Strategy?

> We dive into the insurance world and the strong competition for the top positions on Google, and we compare Allianz and AXA.

- URL: https://www.jaeckert-odaniel.com/en/allianz-vs-axa-who-has-the-better-seo-strategy/
- Language: en
- Published: 2022-02-21
- Updated: 2023-11-14
- Author: [Benjamin O’Daniel](https://www.jaeckert-odaniel.com/en/about-us/benjamin-odaniel/)
- German version: https://www.jaeckert-odaniel.com/allianz-vs-axa-wer-hat-die-bessere-seo-strategie.md
- Topics: seo, content

---

<a slot="topics" href="#vergleich">Visibility in comparison</a>
<a slot="topics" href="#allianz">Allianz: success through topic clusters</a>
<a slot="topics" href="#axa">AXA: many SEO opportunities</a>
<a slot="topics" href="#content-vergleich">High-performance content in comparison</a>

The insurance market is one of the most contested topic fields in search engine optimization. Insurance policies are very well suited to digital sales.

No wonder that by now every large insurance company is betting on SEO. In the podcast, in the livestream on YouTube, and on this page, we compare two large insurers:

- Allianz, with more than 570,000 keywords in the top 100 on Google
- AXA, with more than 170,000 keywords in the top 100 on Google

Which SEO strategies are the two companies using? How are the websites structured? And how is the content built? We discuss that here by way of example, including charts from professional SEO tools.

## Visibility in comparison: Allianz has left AXA clearly behind

Five years ago Allianz and AXA were more or less level. Allianz had 3 points more in overall visibility (SI). Since then the picture has changed markedly. Today Allianz has three to four times more visibility than AXA. The Munich group has expanded its Google visibility clearly over several years. Further on you will also see where this increased visibility comes from. This chart and all further charts come from the SEO suite Sistrix. The index value gives a first impression. Here is more basic background on [SEO visibility](https://www.jaeckert-odaniel.com/en/measuring-seo-visibility-how-we-work-with-index-values/).

[Watch video](https://www.youtube.com/embed/pI4TZgfizDE)

In [this livestream](https://youtu.be/pI4TZgfizDE) we discuss the rankings and the content of both companies in detail. We analyze Allianz's topic-cluster strategy.

We also discuss the equivalent value of SEO: to guide these hundreds of thousands of interested users to the website, you would have to invest a seven-figure sum in Google Ads, in a single product area alone.

## Allianz: success through topic clusters

Allianz has an estimated SEO traffic of 2.2 million clicks per month.

It structures its products in three large directories:

- "Auto, Haus & Recht"
- "Gesundheit & Freizeit"
- "Vorsorge & Vermögen"

The real secret behind it lies deeper, though.

Every single service in turn has its [own content hub](https://www.jaeckert-odaniel.com/en/how-to-build-a-content-hub-for-seo/).

Example: occupational disability insurance (BU). The landing page is at the same time a hub page with 30 further pages hanging under it (see chart 4).

These pages target long-tail terms for:

- target groups ("Studenten", "Schüler", "Azubis")
- occupational groups ("Ärzte", "Physiotherapeuten")
- the customer journey ("Vergleich", "Rechner", "kündigen")

This one content hub on occupational disability insurance alone generates traffic of about 40,000 organic clicks per month.

For comparison: if you bought these clicks from the BU content hub through Google Ads, you would have to spend about 200,000 euros per month.

This cluster strategy was implemented across all services, in some cases with considerably more pages for specific search queries.

In total Allianz has more than 60 pages with top-3 placements and a search volume of more than 3,000 searches per month.

## Deepen your SEO knowledge: every Monday by email

## AXA: many SEO opportunities

AXA has clearly less SEO traffic than Allianz.

AXA does have directories and landing pages for the individual products and services. But no topic clusters hang underneath them. So long-tail terms are not attacked systematically.

In addition, the AXA website does not pass the Core Web Vitals test. So there are technical SEO shortcomings as well. More on the [Core Web Vitals](https://academy.jaeckert-odaniel.com/wie-optimiere-ich-meine-webseite-fuer-die-core-web-vitals/).

Even so, with about 170,000 keywords in the top 100, AXA is anything but badly placed.

It is just often not enough for the absolute top positions.

You also see that when you look more closely at the opportunity keywords: on numerous terms the insurance company is within striking distance, on [page 1, but not in the first positions](https://www.jaeckert-odaniel.com/en/page-1-on-google-three-things-you-should-know/).

You see that in the chart where we filtered all terms with a high cost per click (CPC), high search volume, and top-10 positions. We filtered out the brand mention "AXA" in order to see the purely generic terms.

Example: "Kfz Versicherung".

For this search term alone there are about 100,000 searches per month. In position 7 you get, by projection, about 3,700 clicks per month. At a click price of 14 euros, there is a high Google Ads equivalent value here as well.

## High-performance content in comparison

The challenge with high-performance content: you have to inform and sell at the same time.

[Head terms](https://www.jaeckert-odaniel.com/en/focus-keywords-how-to-rank-for-your-main-terms/), search terms with high search volume, contain different search intents. Some users want to inform themselves first. Others are already looking for concrete solutions.

Using "Berufsunfähigkeitsversicherung" as the example, you can see how differently the two companies solve this challenge.

The AXA landing page is built strongly around sales. The headline itself is clearly promotional. In the visible area at the top, benefits are advertised. Users can choose between "Beitrag berechnen" and "Angebot einfordern."

Allianz, by contrast, has a clear emphasis on information. The visible area is designed more restrained. The option of personal advice is emphasized early with a call-to-action button.

The first content element, "In 30 Sekunden erklärt", targets the most important question: "What is it?" The format has an informational benefit for users, and it also increases time on page.

Both templates have their advantages and disadvantages. What stands out, though, is that at Allianz informational and transactional elements are alternated cleverly. At AXA, by contrast, many informational aspects are hidden in an accordion. An imbalance that can have a negative effect on the SEO ranking.

## SEO from practice: our conversations with practitioners in the field

### [SEO as a growth strategy: interview with Kevin Indig](https://www.jaeckert-odaniel.com/en/seo-as-a-growth-strategy-interview-with-kevin-indig/)

### SEO for a software company: interview with Beat Köck

### [SEO quality assurance: how to protect your rankings. Interview with Gianna Brachetti-Truskawa](https://www.jaeckert-odaniel.com/en/seo-quality-assurance-how-to-protect-your-rankings-interview-with-gianna-brachetti-truskawa/)

### [How Reishunger uses its SEO traffic: interview with Benni Uhlmann](https://www.jaeckert-odaniel.com/en/how-reishunger-uses-its-seo-traffic-interview-with-benni-uhlmann/)

### [How Südwestrundfunk (SWR) works on search experience: interview with Sarah Stein](https://www.jaeckert-odaniel.com/en/how-swr-works-on-search-experience-interview-with-sarah-stein/)

### SEO case study: how Urlaubsguru works. Interview with Sascha Blank

### [How user testing works: interview with Astrid Kramer on UX and SEO](https://www.jaeckert-odaniel.com/en/how-user-testing-works-interview-with-astrid-kramer-on-ux-and-seo/)

### [The SEO strategy of Hubspot: interview with Jenny Lapp](https://www.jaeckert-odaniel.com/en/hubspots-seo-strategy-interview-with-jenny-lapp/)
