# Creation vs. Production: The GPT Dilemma for Content Leads

> Can AI content tools such as ChatGPT shorten idea development and the writing process? We discuss that dilemma for content leads.

- URL: https://www.jaeckert-odaniel.com/en/creation-vs-production-the-gpt-dilemma-for-content-leads/
- Language: en
- Published: 2022-12-19
- Updated: 2025-07-14
- Author: [Benjamin O’Daniel](https://www.jaeckert-odaniel.com/en/about-us/benjamin-odaniel/)
- German version: https://www.jaeckert-odaniel.com/creation-vs-production-das-gpt-dilemma-fuer-content-verantwortliche.md
- Topics: geo, content, seo

---

<a slot="topics" href="#sparringspartner">AI content tools: the new sparring partners?</a>
<a slot="topics" href="#persoenlich">Your personal understanding of quality</a>
<a slot="topics" href="#menschen">The understanding of quality in the company</a>
<a slot="topics" href="#algorithmus">Google's understanding of quality</a>
<a slot="topics" href="#newsletter">More regular SEO insights</a>

When you write texts, there are always two phases: developing ideas. And the writing process. Creation and production.

Both can be an ordeal, especially if you have a standard of quality.

With AI content tools such as ChatGPT, that can now be shortened.

Or not.

That is exactly what we discuss in this podcast episode.

- How do you deal with your **personal** quality standards when you create texts under time pressure?
- Is individual quality recognized by **other people**, by managers, colleagues, clients, and users?
- How will **Google's algorithm** evaluate individually created texts in the future, texts into which a lot of quality ambition has gone?

We discuss exactly these questions in this podcast episode. Our personal impression, and as always a first take. We welcome comments and opinions on LinkedIn.

In general: we are not negative toward developments like this. But we always argue for a critical look and a transparent discussion when they are used in companies.

## AI content tools: the new sparring partners for content leads?

On LinkedIn we are connected with many SEO professionals, copywriters, and content marketing managers. Many of them have used AI content tools such as Jasper, Neuroflash, and ChatGPT in recent weeks and months.

Many are asking whether and **how they can integrate it into their workflows**, and how it makes their work easier. Examples of that are:

- Generating headlines
- Generating [meta descriptions](https://www.jaeckert-odaniel.com/en/how-to-write-meta-titles-and-meta-descriptions/)
- Research summaries
- Creating definitions, tables, and comparisons
- Having tips on a topic generated
- Or creating entire articles directly

The texts are then corrected, edited, and published. Conclusion: you are clearly more productive, or, to put it casually, simply finished faster.

The tools also lead you to new ideas. You do not take the first solution that comes along. You work on being better than the average.

Here is a simple example of generating headlines with [ChatGPT](https://chat.openai.com/). The headlines are generated in a few seconds.

Here you could now copy the best headline, combine several headlines, or use them as a starting point for further brainstorming.

A completely different question, of course, is whether you really want to frame the topic that way. Or whether it would be better to choose a different angle, a different approach. More on that in our [GEO & LLMO workshops](https://www.jaeckert-odaniel.com/en/seo-academy/) as well.

## What about your personal understanding of quality?

Over the years we have met a great many content leads. And we cannot say of any of them that they do not want to get the best out of it. The only thing: **there is simply often not enough time for that**.

That is part of normal reality, and it happens to every working person. So it is always a question of how you produce the best possible result in a manageable amount of time.

AI tools can help here, or they can turn into the exact opposite.

Because developing texts on a blank sheet of paper uses up far more mental capacity than correcting an existing text a little.

It can also be that content leads will in future be expected to create three, five, or ten times as many texts.

At the latest then, quality no longer plays a real role. You become a pure production machine. One that no longer creates texts. But that quickly revises them and puts them online.

In our view there is also the danger that you adopt something too quickly, and in doing so forget to ask the **really important questions**:

- What situation is the target group in?
- What level of knowledge does the target group have?
- Which concrete words do the people use?
- How does the target group react to which topics?

- What specialist expertise do we have?
- What is our specific perspective?
- How can we convey this expertise?
- Would we share the text on LinkedIn?

- Do we earn attention for the result?

With questions like these you develop absolutely unique content. And you meet users on a completely different level.

To say it clearly: **none of this speaks against AI content as a sparring partner. But you should always stay in charge**.

Otherwise you produce a great deal. And still create very little.

## What about the understanding of quality among colleagues, leadership, and clients?

Texts are read by other people. For example by:

- Colleagues
- Team leads, department heads, CEOs
- Website visitors
- Clients

In a company context, texts are often perceived in a purely formal way. The focus is on the length and the number of texts. And rarely on a successful opening or a structured argument.

That could tempt content leads to simply press the button in the AI content tool. But caution: users and clients have a "**bullshit detector**". They recognize completely generic texts and empty phrases immediately, and they switch off immediately. You rarely notice that, though.

Content marketing professionals therefore have a clear responsibility to communicate and present the different levels of quality internally.

A typical AI answer: a coherent answer that looks logical at first glance, with a lot of diplomacy in it. And with many general empty phrases. The first and last sentence can almost always be cut.

A "threat to jobs" is a fairly pointless argument in this context. It will be more about the text simply not triggering anything and being perceived as blah. More here on ChatGPT and websites.

[GEO & LLMO consulting](https://www.jaeckert-odaniel.com/en/geo-llmo-consulting/)

## How does Google evaluate individual quality?

Google itself says quite clearly in the current Helpful Content Update: helpful content, created by people for people, has the best chances of ranking.

At the same time, very similar articles are often in the top 10. There is pressure to conform, and AI content could reinforce exactly that if everyone in future publishes more or less the same content.

Because content can be created so quickly and easily with AI tools, it is likely that many long-tail terms will be targeted with it too, terms for which individually created content hardly pays off, because the effort and the potential return in the form of traffic are not in an adequate ratio.

How will Google deal with that? Our forecast:

**Ranking signals such as E-A-T, meaning expertise, authority, and trust, will be weighted even more strongly in the future**.

Content volume, both in the individual text and in the number of existing articles, will be downgraded as a ranking factor.

Here again: the answer is correct. And at the same time it says little. Let us make it a bit more concrete.

Example: this text here will never rank successfully on Google for keywords such as "KI Tools" or "ChatGPT Erfahrungen". Those terms do appear. And they would certainly also be an informative result for users. But the text is simply not completely focused on the keywords, or optimized for them.

Even the lyrical heading is an obstacle to successful rankings, because a large share of users will probably not understand it, or it is not what they are searching for at that moment. Namely, to have the most important questions answered.

Even so, that is no argument against "SEO content". In our view, SEO-focused content and purely editorial content complement each other perfectly. They fulfill different functions in marketing and for users. It is about finding and retaining.

## Deepen your SEO knowledge: every Monday by email

## We advise marketing leads on SEO

We are Fabian Jaeckert (on the right) and Benjamin O'Daniel. For many years we have advised companies on how to get more visitors through Google and convert that traffic.

> With Jaeckert O'Daniel, it quickly became clear to us that we had made an excellent choice in selecting potential partners for our online marketing project. Their expertise and, above all, their ambition to thoroughly immerse themselves in our specific industry topic to provide us with the best possible support, are precisely what is now propelling us forward.
>
> — Tobias Reitmeier, F.EE Group

Marketing leads have many projects on the table. They know that search engine optimization is relevant. But the concrete implementation, above all developing a solid SEO strategy, is very hard for them.

That is exactly what we have specialized in.

We develop SEO strategies for companies and present them to the people in charge in a structured and understandable way. We then support the in-house leads in the implementation.

Sound interesting? We can arrange a 30-minute SEO intro call by video.

[Get in touch](mailto:info@jaeckert-odaniel.com)

## Our podcast interviews with professionals in the industry

### How user testing works: Interview with Astrid Kramer on UX and SEO

### How Chefkoch dominates the recipe search results: Interview with Hanns Kronenberg

### How to develop international SEO strategies: Interview with Matthäus Michalik

### SEO quality assurance: How to protect your rankings. Interview with Gianna Brachetti-Truskawa

### The art of crawling: Interview with SEO Markus Hövener

### Hubspot's SEO strategy: Interview with Jenny Lapp

### How dm increases its SEO visibility: Interview with Philipp Hassinger

### How Hansgrohe does SEO in 40 countries: Interview with Jörg Niethammer
