# SEO in a Midlife Crisis? Interview with Kevin Indig on AIO, the Google Leak, and the Rise of Communities

> Google, a constant on the web for over two decades, is starting to wobble. Or as the well-known SEO consultant Kevin Indig puts it: a midlife crisis.

- URL: https://www.jaeckert-odaniel.com/en/seo-in-a-midlife-crisis-interview-with-kevin-indig/
- Language: en
- Published: 2024-07-08
- Updated: 2024-07-03
- Author: [Benjamin O’Daniel](https://www.jaeckert-odaniel.com/en/about-us/benjamin-odaniel/)
- German version: https://www.jaeckert-odaniel.com/seo-in-der-midlife-crisis-interview-mit-kevin-indig.md
- Topics: geo, interviews, seo

---

<a slot="topics" href="#aio">AI Overviews: the effects on website traffic</a>
<a slot="topics" href="#leak">Google leak: what SEO leads need to do now</a>
<a slot="topics" href="#communities">The rise of communities</a>

Google, a constant on the web for over two decades, is starting to wobble. Or, as the well-known SEO consultant Kevin Indig puts it: "Google is in a midlife crisis."

We take that as the hook to talk with Kevin about current developments.

We talk about his current studies on AI Overviews, about core updates that are hard to analyze, his findings from the Google leak, and the rise of communities, which are gaining more and more visibility.

And in the end it always comes down to this question too: **what will SEO managers do in the future? What is their role, and how will the profession change?** More on that in the interview.

Kevin also reports on his own studies and on his impression of the large companies in the US.

## About our guest

Kevin Indig started his career at the SEO enterprise tool Searchmetrics, for which he went to Silicon Valley at the time. After stops at fast-growing startups such as Atlassian and G2, he moved to Shopify as Director of SEO.

After that, Kevin went independent. With a focus on growth that goes beyond SEO. He advises well-known US companies such as Reddit and Dropbox. There he works with the CMOs and the SEO content teams.

For example when CMOs ask whether and how their SEO teams are working, how they can improve the staffing structure, but also specialist questions such as how to set up better reporting from SEO traffic to revenue.

What we personally love: **Kevin shares a great deal of specialist knowledge too.** His focus is on industry analyses in which he looks not only at SEO data, but at general user behavior and market trends.

- [Kevin Indig on LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/in/kevinindig/)
- [His Growth Memo newsletter](https://www.growth-memo.com/)
- An earlier interview of ours with Kevin Indig

<Video url="https://youtube.com/shorts/YIWvsx0ETfI" portrait />

## AI Overviews: effects on Google clicks

How do AI Overviews affect clicks? That is the central question occupying many SEO experts. After all, you want to know how strongly the technological changes affect website traffic and the channel.

Kevin ran his own study on this and updated it recently too ([the article is here](https://www.growth-memo.com/p/aio-pullback)).

His study found: on search terms where an AI answer was integrated, **clicks fell by about 9 percent**. A clear cut, but also worlds away from website traffic collapsing overall.

In the interview, Kevin compares it to featured snippets, the highlighted answer boxes that appear right at the top.

With featured snippets you see the same thing: click rates vary widely. For simple questions and answers (such as weather or stock prices), users click less often. When they want to go deeper, click rates are very high. "It depends very heavily on the keyword," Kevin says. Search terms that often drive revenue (leads, sales) are less affected.

Google also scaled AI Overviews back sharply after the PR disaster in which numerous media outlets published examples where the AI answers were wrong, misleading, or even dangerous. Google said, by the way, that many of the examples were fake ([Benjamin's LinkedIn post on that](https://www.linkedin.com/posts/benjamin-o-daniel_seo-aioverview-google-activity-7202278302303039488-R9q4)).

## Google leak: what it means for SEO managers

The Google leak revealed: Google uses user data very heavily to determine rankings. More precisely: [clicks and views](https://www.jaeckert-odaniel.com/en/clicks-and-views-as-new-ranking-factors-insights-from-the-google-leak/). Kevin sees three categories of user signals:

- **Search behavior**: brands or companies that are searched in combination with generic terms have a very good chance on the generic term itself (example chart).
- **Website behavior**: through Chrome, Google collects data on whether websites are actually viewed. If they are, that is a strong signal that the content is good.
- **Search result behavior**: this is about how users behave on the search results themselves, for example whether they jump back to the search.

For SEO leads that means: they have to analyze user signals even more strongly, such as time on page, scroll depth, and back-button behavior, and they also have to look even more closely at user experience (UX). For example, design decisions related to website features.

Example: travel websites that Kevin analyzed recently. The travel portal Kayak tested how users behave when you show more or fewer results in the carousel, or when you add service elements and show when it is best to book the flight.

But are SEOs really responsible for that? Or web designers much more so? This is exactly where Kevin sees **the interface role that many SEO managers have**.

They have to show what consequences certain decisions have for SEO, or for Google as a traffic channel, and how to make the right decisions.

The same thing already shows up now, for example in relaunch projects, in content creation, or in collaboration with product departments that develop terms for products which run counter to how customers search.

## The rise of communities

Another development: communities and forums have seen a strong rise in SEO visibility in recent months. The best-known example is Reddit, which now has half as much visibility as Amazon, and long since much more visibility than the New York Times, for example (see the visibility chart from Sistrix).

But not only Reddit. Other communities, such as the forum areas of Hubspot or Zapier, are seeing a strong rise too. How does that happen?

Kevin himself suspects that Google wants to put a stronger focus on "human" feedback in the search results. **As a counterweight to search results with general and also AI-generated content**.

Users themselves also want more and more Reddit-specific content, which you can read from brand search.

For companies that also means: if they have already built very high SEO visibility, their own communities can be a further SEO lever. Also because new brand search and positive user signals arise through them, and because in the end you make yourself more independent of all platforms.

On content, Kevin's impression is: "On the one hand, with the right processes you can now generate very good AI content. On the other hand, any content that is demonstrably created by humans is currently incredibly valuable."

## Deepen your SEO knowledge: every Monday by email

## We advise marketing leads on SEO

We are Fabian Jaeckert (on the right) and Benjamin O'Daniel. For many years we have worked as consultants for marketing teams. In doing so we connect two worlds: Fabian is the technical expert, Benjamin takes on every topic around content development.

> For our marketing team, we specifically sought a sparring partner for SEO and content. Our goal was to gain new external insights to better leverage our ranking potential as a well-known brand in our market segment. Fabian and Benjamin delved deeply into our needs, and thanks to their comprehensive, data-driven analysis, they were able to provide us with concrete optimization suggestions for our SEO strategy. We particularly appreciated that we could achieve our goal with existing resources and focused testing.
>
> — Bernd Günther, Sage

"How can we improve our SEO visibility?"

This fundamental question sits behind every project we are brought into.

It is often about reviewing existing SEO and content strategies from the outside and developing new levers.

That is exactly what we have specialized in.

We develop SEO strategies for companies and present them in focus workshops, in a structured and understandable way, to the people responsible. Afterwards we support the in-house leads during implementation.

Sound interesting?

We can arrange an introductory SEO video call (30 min.).

[Get in touch](mailto:info@jaeckert-odaniel.com)

## Our conversations with SEO professionals in the industry

### How Südwestrundfunk (SWR) works on search experience: Interview with Sarah Stein

### SEO for a software company: Interview with Beat Köck

### SEO for software companies: Interview with Lisa Karasch

### Landing pages for software companies: Interview with Thomas Kemp

### What does an online shop need in order to rank successfully? Interview with Stefan Vorwerk

### The SEO strategy of Hubspot: Interview with Jenny Lapp

### How user testing works: Interview with Astrid Kramer on UX and SEO

### SEO for a furniture startup: Interview with Manon Tolkowski
