# Site Reputation Abuse: When Publishers Misuse Their Reputation - and What the Alternative Is

> Google is tightening its spam measures, and publishers are feeling it now. Site Reputation Abuse means misusing a website's reputation.

- URL: https://www.jaeckert-odaniel.com/en/site-reputation-abuse-when-publishers-misuse-their-reputation/
- Language: en
- Published: 2024-05-20
- Updated: 2025-01-28
- Author: [Benjamin O’Daniel](https://www.jaeckert-odaniel.com/en/about-us/benjamin-odaniel/)
- German version: https://www.jaeckert-odaniel.com/site-reputation-abuse-wenn-verlage-ihren-guten-ruf-missbrauchen-und-was-die-alternative-ist.md
- Topics: seo

---

<a slot="topics" href="#beispiel">The search results Google wants to fight</a>
<a slot="topics" href="#verluste">These websites have already lost</a>
<a slot="topics" href="#verboten">Site Reputation Abuse: This is prohibited</a>
<a slot="topics" href="#erlaubt">... and this is allowed</a>
<a slot="topics" href="#alternativen">2 approaches for publishers</a>

Google is tightening the reins on its spam measures - and publishers are now feeling it. "Site Reputation Abuse" is the keyword. In plain language: the misuse of the website's reputation. Here is a current article at [SEO Südwest](https://seo-suedwest.de/9640-google-manuelle-massnahmen-wegen-site-reputation-abuse-in-deutschland-angekommen.html).

What is behind it, which publishers are currently dropping in the Google rankings - and what the alternative is. We discuss that in our podcast. The core statements are here in the article.

Up front: we are white-hat SEOs. That means we always work with the guidelines - and not against Google. We consider deliberate action against the rules ineffective, because in the end you are always at a disadvantage. At best you celebrate tactical wins - but at the cost of constant reworking and adjustments.

## Example: The search results Google wants to fight

Around 70,000 users a month search for Otto Gutschein (Otto coupon) (source: SEO tool Sistrix). Whoever ranks at the front here gets the clicks that come with it. Five well-known German publishers are in the top 10. Each with a subdomain.

Without knowing the technical and organizational infrastructure behind it, you get the impression that the content is being published there automatically.

It is also often stated explicitly that this is a service of a company other than the media house. In practice that means: the publisher makes part of its website available to others. At the same time, the content only ranks in the top 10 because the publishers' domains enjoy very high trust and have also been linked often.

That is exactly what Google now prohibits with the expansion of its spam policy (here is the relevant passage [in the documentation](https://developers.google.com/search/docs/essentials/spam-policies?hl=de#site-reputation)).

## These websites have already lost

In the US and the UK, a whole series of well-known publishers have had to accept severe losses in their coupon sections. Among them Reuters, Time, Wired, The Independent, and many more. In the short video we present a publisher website from the UK whose coupon directory has lost a lot of SEO visibility.

These appear to be manual actions, as colleague Christian Kunz [reports](https://www.seo-suedwest.de/9304-google-hebt-erste-manuelle-massnahmen-wegen-site-reputation-abuse-auf.html) on SEO Südwest. That means: these are not algorithmic measures that are switched on and rolled out. They are penalties issued one by one.

In its spam policies, Google itself recommends setting the relevant directories to noindex and thus taking them out of the rankings. It is unlikely that publishers will do this voluntarily, because the commercial success of the directories also depends on SEO traffic.

## Site Reputation Abuse: This is prohibited

The central sentence comes right at the start: "Site reputation abuse occurs when third-party pages are published with little or no control or involvement by the first party, and the purpose is to manipulate search rankings by exploiting the ranking signals of the first-party site."

It is exactly these third parties that, for example, fill the coupon sections. The sections only rank on Google because of the publishers' ranking signals. Publishers are often linked from trustworthy external sources and therefore have a high domain rating in SEO.

Google also wants to stop reviews that are published without checks and without any involvement. This is probably about comparisons where the editorial team often contributes nothing, and Amazon reviews are embedded so that affiliate revenue is generated.

## ... and this is allowed

What also becomes clear: Google explicitly wants to act only against abuse of Google's reputation - not against the advertising business of media companies in principle. It is stressed, for example, that advertorials or native advertising formats do not violate the spam policies.

## 2 approaches for media companies

**Stick to the guidelines**

As simple as it sounds: Google itself states in its spam policies what is possible and what is not. Media companies should set the relevant coupon directories to noindex and write off the losses. They are often side businesses. They contribute nothing to the central future strategy - namely winning more digital subscribers. On the contrary: you actually damage your good reputation. These are decisions that ultimately have to be made at management level - and not by the in-house SEO leads.

**SEO strategies for more subscriptions**

Many publishers are very successful with their digital products - and with the analysis behind them. Spiegel, for example, said some time ago which articles [generate the most digital subscriptions](https://www.spiegel.de/backstage/fuenf-jahre-spiegel-in-der-analyse-ueber-wen-schreiben-wir-am-meisten-was-wird-am-besten-gelesen-a-11e8f9e6-0ab0-4b74-8996-1b6677cc9b15). From our point of view, SEO should connect exactly here. How do you get more SEO visibility for the articles and topic areas? After all, these topics convert very well. We always follow exactly these approaches in our [SEO consulting](https://www.jaeckert-odaniel.com/en/consulting/). We work on the most important line of business - and develop SEO strategies and measures there.

## We advise marketing leads on SEO

We are Fabian Jaeckert (on the right) and Benjamin O'Daniel. For many years we have worked as consultants for marketing teams. We combine two worlds: Fabian is the technical expert, Benjamin covers everything around content development.

"How can we improve our SEO visibility?"

This basic question sits behind every project we are brought into.

Often it is about reviewing existing SEO and content strategies from the outside and developing new levers.

That is exactly what we specialize in.

We develop SEO strategies for companies and present them in focus workshops, in a structured and understandable way, to the people in charge. Then we support the in-house leads as they put them into practice.

Sound interesting?

We can arrange an SEO intro meeting by video call (30 min.).

[Get in touch](mailto:info@jaeckert-odaniel.com)

## Deepen your SEO knowledge: every Monday by email

## Our conversations with SEO professionals in the industry

### SEO Quality Assurance: How to Protect Your Rankings - Interview with Gianna Brachetti-Truskawa

### How Südwestrundfunk (SWR) Works on Search Experience: Interview with Sarah Stein

### SEO as a Growth Strategy: Interview with Kevin Indig

### SEO for a Software Company: Interview with Beat Köck

### What Does an Online Shop Need to Rank Successfully? Interview with Stefan Vorwerk

### How Hansgrohe Does SEO in 40 Countries: Interview with Jörg Niethammer

### Hubspot's SEO Strategy: Interview with Jenny Lapp

### How User Testing Works: Interview with Astrid Kramer on UX and SEO
