Skip to content

September 23, 2024Fabian Jaeckert

75% Dark Keywords in SEO: Most Traffic Drivers Are a Secret (Analysis)

At the end of the day, SEO is always about getting more website traffic. You can use Google Search Console to analyze which keywords bring how much traffic.

Or so you would think. Anyone who looks at the data more closely will notice: Google Search Console shows only a small slice of these keywords.

A large share of the keywords that bring traffic is simply missing. Which keywords those are is what we worked out in this SEO analysis. The results matter. Because this is about:

  • which kinds of keywords actually bring traffic in the end
  • not letting “search volume” be the only thing that drives you
  • judging the data basis correctly

Ready for the deep dive? Then we suggest this: open your Google Search Console and walk the same path on your own website. That way you can follow it more easily. Send us feedback, by email or on LinkedIn.

Dark keywords in GSC

Domain level: 75% of the keywords that bring website traffic are not shown

In Google Search Console, the performance report shows how many clicks a keyword has. The default is 3 months. In this example (one of our own guide pages) we set 6 months, so we would have more data to work from. Below the chart, the individual keywords are shown as well. You can also analyze pages and set filters there.

At the top right you can export this keyword data at domain level. For example into a Google Sheet. The second column always shows how many clicks each keyword brought.

If you add up all the clicks in the table, you will find: far fewer traffic keywords are listed than the clicks the domain received in total. So keywords that brought clicks are missing.

And quite a lot of them. To be precise, it is around 75 percent. We checked this on further domains as examples.

The reverse is this: you know only 25 percent of the keywords that actually bring clicks. The rest is unknown.

That is an important starting point. Because in the end, as SEO consultants, we want to know which search terms really bring website traffic. So in the next step we set out to determine which kinds of keywords the ones we do not know actually are.

Domain SEO traffic, Google Search Console example

Website SEO keywords export function

Keywords in Google Sheets, traffic added up

Long-tail keywords on a URL: here, too, 75% are dark keywords

Next we checked a single URL using the same method. In this case a guide article that received about 1,600 clicks via specific keywords in 6 months. A long-tail keyword analysis. The keywords shown here add up to only 400 clicks.

So 75 percent of all clicks and keywords are missing here as well. We do not know which search terms accounted for most of the success in the end. We only see a small slice.

This fact has consequences:

Keyword assessment: the long tail is often neglected because SEO tools show only low search volumes for it. The example shows, though, that many unknown long-tail keywords generate a great deal of website traffic in total. The long tail should move further into focus.

Content production: in the long tail it makes little sense to optimize for individual keywords. In the end you do not know which wording will throw off keyword traffic. From our point of view it is better if the known keywords set the rough frame, a pattern, and you then work with more editorial freedom. Here we see a shift toward Ranch Style SEO and First Hand Experience.

SEO traffic, URL example

Keywords and clicks at URL level, example

Impressions compared: there are only 33% dark impressions

Using the same method, you can analyze impressions in Google Search Console. What shows up: we get a lot of information on which keywords our analyzed URL generates how many impressions for. The result: there are only 33 percent dark impressions. 66 percent of all impressions are known. At URL level and at domain level.

If you combine the two data sets, clicks with impressions, you get an interesting result.

75 percent of all dark clicks fall on 33 percent of all dark impressions.

That means: the unknown keywords that bring clicks account for only a few impressions. They are extremely niche long-tail keywords that are rarely searched, but very efficient.

We tested this at URL level. There we had 20,000 dark impressions that produced 1,200 dark clicks. That is 16.6 dark impressions per dark click. A dark CTR of 6%.

By comparison, the known keywords perform clearly worse. Around 40,000 known impressions produced 400 known keyword clicks. That is 100 impressions per click. CTR: 1%.

Here, too, we tested the impressions in Google Search Console across various examples and, for similar content, arrive at similar results.

Short-head keywords: here there are only 25 percent dark keywords

Using the same method, we also checked articles that rank for head keywords. That is, one-word search terms with four- or five-digit search volumes per month. We cannot and do not want to provide charts for this, because these are client projects.

The articles generate thousands of clicks. So the data basis is valid here as well. If you look at how many traffic keywords are shown, there is a surprising result: for content that ranks for short-head terms, 75 percent of all keywords that bring traffic are shown. The exact reverse of the long-tail example.

With short-head keywords, then, we are told precisely which search terms bring keyword traffic. Most of it often falls on that one word and is shown accordingly.

If an article or a URL ranks in the short head, that same one-word ranking throws off most of the traffic. There are only a few unknown long-tail terms that bring additional traffic. A very high dependency.

What also remains:

There is a strong distortion in the keyword click data. On the surface it looks as if the head terms throw off far more website traffic than the long tail. But in the depth you see that this is because the long-tail keywords are shown only to a very limited extent.

Conclusion of the SEO analysis

Short-head: all or nothing

If you rank for keywords with a strong search volume, this applies: all or nothing. If you stand right at the front, almost all of the traffic comes through that one keyword alone. The traffic is extremely concentrated. It is correspondingly brutal when you drop for that term. Or when you never manage to reach top positions here in the first place, which is not rare, because the competition is very strong.

Long-tail: nothing or everything

For the long tail, the reverse principle applies: nothing or everything. The long tail often drops to the bottom of the content plan, because SEO managers only look at search volume. But when a long-tail URL ranks successfully, 75 percent more traffic comes in through unknown keywords. The articles or pages throw off much more than you thought.

We advise marketing leads on SEO

Running an SEO content audit

We are Fabian Jaeckert (on the right) and Benjamin O’Daniel. For many years we have worked as consultants for marketing teams. We connect two worlds: Fabian is the technical expert, Benjamin takes on everything around content development.

  • For anyone seeking an SEO sparring partner or comprehensive SEO consulting, Fabian and Benjamin are the perfect choice. As an in-house SEO expert, I sought competent SEO support and found it with them. During a very pleasant introductory meeting, we jointly developed an approach to establish SEO among the individual stakeholders and thereby gain more internal visibility for the subject. Based on this initial discussion and a joint kick-off with the stakeholders, they developed a sound SEO and content strategy for a product area. Since then, they have both supported me as sparring partners during implementation.

    The collaboration with Fabian and Benjamin is a great pleasure for me and all project participants, as they are masters of their craft and bring immense passion for SEO. This combination is infectious and motivates everyone to achieve peak performance.

    Regina BiskopDeutsche Kreditbank AG

“How can we improve our SEO visibility?”

That basic question sits behind every project we are brought into.

Often it is about reviewing existing SEO and content strategies from the outside and developing new levers.

That is exactly what we specialize in.

We develop SEO strategies for companies and present them, in focus workshops, in a structured and understandable way to the people responsible. After that we support the in-house leads through implementation.

Sounds interesting?

We can set up an SEO intro call by video conference (30 min.).

Deepen your SEO knowledge: every Monday by email

GEO SEO newsletter

Our conversations with SEO professionals from the industry

How Südwestrundfunk (SWR) works on search experience: interview with Sarah Stein

SEO as a growth strategy: interview with Kevin Indig

SEO for a software company: interview with Beat Köck

SEO for software companies: interview with Lisa Karasch

What does an online shop need to rank successfully? Interview with Stefan Vorwerk

How Hansgrohe does SEO in 40 countries: interview with Jörg Niethammer

The relaunch SEO checklist: interview with Regina Biskop of DKB

How the SaaS startup awork builds its SEO visibility: interview with Ayla Grzegowski

Topics