September 26, 2022Benjamin O’Daniel
Relaunch or Redesign: Which Is the Better Option?
When a corporate website is to be changed on a larger scale, that means one thing first for marketing: a lot of work.
Technology, design, structure, content, SEO: many topics land on the table.
Often all of these points are fused into one large project, the so-called relaunch.
Once set in motion, the relaunch then blocks the pipeline in marketing for months.
The term that comes up less often, by contrast: redesign. A significantly smaller project.
In the podcast episode and on this page we want to discuss exactly that: when, from our point of view, does a corporate website really need a relaunch? And when is a redesign enough?
What is a website relaunch?
A website relaunch covers larger changes in the technology, in the website design, in the structure, and in the content. The most frequent occasion is the switch to another content management system (CMS), from which you expect more or which is (supposedly) necessary for technical reasons.
Another occasion is dissatisfaction with the look of the website. Marketing then hopes for more design options through a different CMS.
In the course of that, the website structure and the content are also discussed. And in a further step search engine optimization (SEO) too, because the website should after all be as findable as possible and should bring more visitors. So that the investment is also worth it.
Comprehensive relaunches often cost a high five-figure sum. Six-figure sums are not rare either, when the company is larger or many products are shown on the website.
What is a redesign?
We talk about a redesign when a website is to get a new design. That covers colors, shapes, typefaces, but also the structural design of individual pages and general usability.
The redesign concerns above all the design of the website that is visible to the user. And not the backend, the CMS that sits behind it.
In general every CMS offers very different options in design. Large systems such as Typo3, WordPress, and Drupal are extremely flexible in design.
From our point of view, people talk far too rarely about whether a redesign is not enough. It is assumed too hastily that with a certain CMS you simply have no way to a better design.
The concrete visual wishes often stay vague in the process. We argue that you formulate your requirements clearly, and on that basis get quotes.
A redesign also has clear advantages from an SEO point of view. Because the URL structure stays intact as a result. Because many websites already have Google rankings (which many marketing leads are not fully aware of, because they lack the SEO tools for such an analysis).

We discuss here which CMS supports SEO as well as possible.
2 situations in which a redesign can be enough
New functions
If you are unhappy with the usability and the function of the content management system, a switch to a new CMS is not the only option.
Alternatively you can also note specifically what exactly is hard to operate and derive requirements from that, which you clarify with IT. Often these functions are already there, just not activated or integrated.
Sometimes a relaunch is also carried out because the new CMS promises an integration with the product data (PIM) or customer management (CRM). Here too, though, you should definitely check beforehand whether there might also be interface solutions for the existing system.
SEO requirements
People often hope that a relaunch will get them more SEO visibility. But a new CMS alone does not help with that. For this you need an SEO strategy consisting of keywords, architecture, and targeted content.
Sure, a CMS should be fit for search engines. So guarantee indexability by Google. From our experience, though, that is always given with every larger CMS looked after by professional web developers.
On top of that, a relaunch onto a new system always also puts the existing rankings at risk. Unfortunately we see it more often that companies have less SEO traffic after a relaunch than before, because the switch was not carried out properly.
The goals behind a relaunch or redesign
Simple management
Marketing leads need the ability to fill and change individual pages, such as landing pages, themselves. The handling has to be as simple as possible and, above all, work independently of IT. A content management system has to provide this usability. And that is exactly the goal you should work toward together with the web developers.
Top user experience
A CMS has to be easy for users to understand. The success factors for this are the design, the navigation structure, and technical factors such as a fast load time. That makes users stay longer on the website. And with that the chance also rises that users get in touch with the company, so that leads or sales are generated.
More SEO reach
Whether relaunch or redesign: in the end it is about the website also reaching more people overall. For that, SEO is a central discipline that provides better Google rankings and, as a result, more traffic, leads, and sales. The basis for that is a professional SEO strategy.
Conclusion: website relaunch or redesign?

We are Fabian Jaeckert (on the right) and Benjamin O’Daniel. For many years we have advised companies on how to get more visitors through Google and turn that traffic into inquiries and sales. So that the website becomes a measure that supports sales. Through high-quality content.
With Jaeckert O’Daniel, it quickly became clear to us that we had made an excellent choice in selecting potential partners for our online marketing project. Their expertise and, above all, their ambition to thoroughly immerse themselves in our specific industry topic to provide us with the best possible support, are precisely what is now propelling us forward.
Tobias ReitmeierF.EE Group
From our point of view, comprehensive relaunches are decided far too quickly, and then carried out without being questioned. Even though the costs and the internal effort are extremely high. A redesign is often more manageable in implementation than a relaunch. The whole project is less complex, cheaper, and lower risk, above all for SEO.
Marketing managers have many projects on their desk. They know that search engine optimization matters. But the concrete implementation, above all developing a solid SEO strategy, is very hard for them.
That is exactly what we specialize in. We develop SEO strategies for companies and present them to the people in charge in a structured and understandable way. After that we support the in-house leads during implementation.
Sound interesting? We can set up an SEO intro meeting by video conference (30 min.).
Our podcast conversations with professionals in the industry

How user testing works: interview with Astrid Kramer on UX and SEO

The SEO strategy of Reishunger.de: interview with Benni Uhlmann

SEO for a software company: interview with Beat Köck

Community management in companies: interview with Vivian Pein

How to build a successful startup: interview with Johannes Kliesch

How do I become a personal brand, without crude advertising for myself? Interview with Kerstin Hoffmann

Passage ranking: who benefits from it, and how. Interview with Alexander Rus







