Skip to content

22. September 2025Fabian Jaeckert

Why SEO is part of GEO - and not the other way around

In the SEO world we see an interesting pattern: optimization for AI systems is treated as a sub-discipline of SEO.

The motto: we will just do a bit of that as well.

This view rests on three central arguments, which we criticize in this article. From our point of view, people are vastly underestimating how large the shift is. A little adjustment is not enough.

In the future, everything will revolve around visibility and relevance in AI systems. The “old Google” plays an important, but secondary, role.

Why SEO is part of GEO - and not the other way around

1. Argument: “AI systems play only a secondary role”

A number of studies have appeared recently that stress that AI systems play only a secondary role compared with Google. One example is the study from Cloudflare (discussed here by our colleague Christian Kunz of SEO Südwest). What matters, though, is the comparison metric: every time, the share of traffic is used. In other words, which sources clicks on websites come from.

This view has several catches, though:

  • Wrong metric: In AI systems, users basically no longer have to click. They get their answers directly in the AI chat. AI systems will therefore always drive less traffic.
  • Unknown usage: ChatGPT (and other AI systems) has been at number 1 in the app-store download charts for months. What happens inside this app is not measured.
  • Google is changing too: Google is also turning into an AI system. Whether through AI Mode, which has already been rolled out worldwide. Or through its own AI app, Gemini.

It is completely clear that use of AI systems is still comparatively at the beginning. But it is a completely distorted view if you look at today’s pure traffic numbers and base your future strategy on them.

2. Argument: “If you do SEO, you do GEO along with it”

How you optimize for visibility and relevance in AI systems: the industry is still right at the beginning here. Measures that get recommended include, for example, the “GEO optimization” of content. The advice is to watch for understandable language, short paragraphs, and keywords, so exactly the same measures as in SEO. One argument for this is: if you rank at the top in Google, you are used as a source more often.

This line of argument has several weaknesses too:

  • How AI works: AI systems can “understand” and structure complex texts on their own. They do not need “bite-sized” texts for that.
  • Search as a sub-function: The search function in AI systems is a secondary function. SEO is therefore a part of GEO.
  • Grounding process: Sometimes the AI activates grounding, meaning search as part of generating the AI answer. Then, though, a series of search queries is run, evaluated, and processed further. The process is much more complex. The old formula “top ranking = traffic” holds only to a limited extent.

More on this in this article of ours: GEO texts are not SEO texts.

3. Argument: “SEO is measurable. AI optimization is not”

People stress that in SEO, rankings and traffic are measurable. In AI systems, by contrast, the answers are supposedly different every time. There is nothing you can hold on to in an analysis. Here too you find several counterarguments:

  • Rankings become worthless: Since the introduction of AI Overviews, it is clear: even if you are in position 1, you suffer serious traffic losses. Many users are satisfied with the AI summary and click much less often. Rankings already say hardly anything.
  • Empty keywords, dark keywords: In practice you see it again and again: some keywords supposedly have very high search volume, but they deliver hardly any traffic anymore. The reasons are varied: Google Ads, Google integrations, bot traffic. Conversely, in the long tail, 75 percent of keywords are not visible (Dark Keywords). A lot in SEO has not been that clear for a long time.
  • AI visibility analytics: Even if AI systems do not always give exactly the same answer: if you measure your prompts over a longer period, you get comparable answers and stable industry rankings. More here on KPIs in GEO & LLMO.

OpenAI’s research team, together with a Harvard economist and the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER), produced a study. For it, 1.5 million prompts were evaluated anonymously. It is the first study that shows in depth how ChatGPT is used.

Three central findings:

  • Private use: Private use keeps growing. The share of non-work-related messages rose from 53 percent (June 2024) to 73 percent (June 2025).
  • Use like a search engine: In private use, “Practical Guidance” and “Information Seeking” make up 53 percent of use (page 15). Both are typical activities that people otherwise carried out via Google.
  • Search is rising: “Information Seeking” is growing, from 18 percent to 24.4 percent in one year. Searching for products is part of that (“Purchasable Products”). Many integrations, such as the shopping feed, have also only existed for a short time.

People with higher education in particular use ChatGPT for search and decision-making. ChatGPT gives them tailored answers and new ideas. The information for that comes from the language model and the integrated search (“grounding”).

According to the study, around 10 percent of the world’s population already uses ChatGPT. You have to add this: ChatGPT is only one AI system among many. Other AI systems are advancing as well.

Here is the study (PDF document and press release from OpenAI.)

Your input on GEO & LLMO: our newsletter

GEO SEO newsletter

We advise marketing leads on SEO

  • For anyone seeking an SEO sparring partner or comprehensive SEO consulting, Fabian and Benjamin are the perfect choice. As an in-house SEO expert, I sought competent SEO support and found it with them. During a very pleasant introductory meeting, we jointly developed an approach to establish SEO among the individual stakeholders and thereby gain more internal visibility for the subject. Based on this initial discussion and a joint kick-off with the stakeholders, they developed a sound SEO and content strategy for a product area. Since then, they have both supported me as sparring partners during implementation.

    The collaboration with Fabian and Benjamin is a great pleasure for me and all project participants, as they are masters of their craft and bring immense passion for SEO. This combination is infectious and motivates everyone to achieve peak performance.

    Regina BiskopDeutsche Kreditbank AG
  • I look back with great satisfaction on the SEO project that we carried out with Benjamin and Fabian. Firstly, the collaboration was on a very pleasant, goal-oriented level. Secondly, the consultation was structured in such a way that we could immediately start with the implementation. We received very concrete optimization suggestions that were tailored to our internal capacities and therefore realistically implementable. Even though only a few months have passed, we can already see the first results of our work in the Google rankings. Traffic for our relevant keywords is steadily increasing, and we still have enough concrete work packages from Benjamin in the pipeline to boost our site. Furthermore, through the consultation, we have acquired so much internal SEO know-how that we can now optimize our site independently. And most importantly: Visitor numbers have doubled – with correspondingly positive effects on sales.

    Mark MaudererDigital Marketing Manager, Bierbaum Proenen

Our conversations with SEO and GEO professionals in the industry

How SEO copywriters work with ChatGPT: interview with Monika Weber

How the SaaS startup awork builds its SEO visibility: interview with Ayla Grzegowski

How Hansgrohe does SEO in 40 countries: interview with Jörg Niethammer

SEO for software companies: interview with Lisa Karasch