January 21, 2019Fabian Jaeckert
Google's Quality Rater Guidelines: What You Can Learn from Them
The Google Quality Rater Guidelines are a very interesting document that plays an ever larger role in search engine optimization.
The Google algorithm does not depend on the Quality Rater Guidelines. But the guidelines show principles that matter to Google.
We go through the roughly 130-page document piece by piece. We analyze the examples and place them in the various SEO disciplines and requirements.
Three common questions about Google’s Search Quality Rater Guidelines
What are the Search Quality Rater Guidelines?
The guidelines are internal training materials for Google employees. They are meant to rate the quality of websites manually, using a schema. The internal document was leaked a few years ago. Google has since decided to publish it. The guidelines are updated regularly, and that then draws corresponding attention in the SEO industry. You can download the document here.
What is in the Quality Rater Guidelines?
The document first sets out the basics of the context in which websites stand in search. Central topic: does the website meet the user’s search intent? And: how good is the content? To determine quality, Google built the so-called E-A-T model. Further on, websites are described with high quality, medium quality, and poor quality. This is backed up with numerous examples.
What role do the guidelines play in everyday SEO?
In our view it is essential to understand the Search Quality Rater Guidelines. It is about a fundamental view of how Google looks at its search. All Google core updates of recent years have always served to improve quality for the user. We see ourselves as white hat SEO. That means: we work with Google, and not against Google. Our approach: we create the best search result for a search query.
SEO sparring partner for marketing leads
For more than 15 years we have worked in search engine optimization and in content. In our consulting we combine these two worlds: SEO and content.
We advise companies in the form of SEO concepts and SEO sparring. In our SEO Academy we explain how to put search engine optimization into practice in everyday work and integrate it efficiently into your work processes.
That is exactly the central topic of Google’s Search Quality Rater Guidelines: the content of websites, on the content level and in the external profile, which is summed up under E-A-T. More about us and our references.

SEO from practice: our podcast interviews
In our online marketing podcast we talk about SEO every week. We analyze a topic, or we invite well-known top speakers from the industry and talk with them about a specialist subject.

SEO for a Software Company: Interview with Beat Köck

How Do I Become a LinkedIn Influencer? Interview with Jens Polomski

Community Management in Companies: Interview with Vivian Pein

How Do I Become a Personal Brand – without Crude Self-Promotion? Interview with Kerstin Hoffmann

How to Build a Successful Startup: Interview with Johannes Kliesch
Google’s Quality Rater Guidelines: our experience in brief
Why we find the Quality Rater Guidelines important
- Crystal ball vs. primary source
- Algorithm vs. human
- Your own criteria vs. a criteria catalog
Three components and episodes
- EAT model
- Page Quality
- Search intent
Purpose of a website
- Is the website helpful for the user
- All purposes are equal
- The best answer for the search intent
Conclusion
- User-centered way of thinking
- Webmasters do not appear









