Skip to content

September 30, 2024Benjamin O’Daniel

First Hand Experience: The Content Key in the New AI World

I have been writing professionally for over 15 years, and I can say this: I have never produced the perfect article. Every piece sits between my personal standards and my eye on the clock. The clock almost always wins.

My takeaway from daily work: I can spend hours polishing the last word. But the real quality lever is somewhere else: in developing the topic idea. When the idea fits - the topic, the keywords, the angle - the article works.

That is exactly what this podcast episode with Fabian, and this article, are about. How can you develop topic ideas that deliver? With a view to the fact that

  • SEO competition in the top 10 keeps increasing
  • AI answers are being built into Google Search
  • alternative answer engines such as ChatGPT are establishing themselves

The key is content with “First Hand Experience”. An approach Google itself stresses. An approach the industry keeps circling around. And one we want to fill with life here. For us, it is a central part of a GEO & LLMO strategy.

First Hand Experience content

What is “First Hand Experience” content?

There are two core documents in which Google uses the term “First Hand Experience” or “First Hand Expertise”:

In both documents, Google stresses that its ranking systems prefer content written for people, and not optimized for search. Content that contains real experience and real knowledge, and not purely compiled copy.

But what does that mean in practice? Is this kind of content really preferred? And how are you supposed to build it systematically into content development? Those are the questions the SEO community discusses a lot.

Creating this kind of content is, of course, more work, and it needs entirely new approaches in editorial planning and topic development.

Google Quality Rater Guidelines P.25 First Hand Experience Page Quality

Google Search Central focus on people-first content

3 challenges for people responsible for content

Strong sameness in the top 10 search results

The top 10 search results are often strikingly uniform. Take head terms: you do not find one article on the “definition”, but five to eight articles with a “what is it” heading. Because those articles rank at the front, more and more of them get produced and optimized. The question is: if you, as the person responsible for content, produce an article like that, what chance do you still have of winning a top ranking at all? And will users even click when there is no difference left? The poor click-through rates (CTR) on these terms speak for themselves. You need new content approaches to draw out differences.

SEO content processes trimmed for efficiency

Over 20 years of SEO, content processes have been trimmed further and further for efficiency. Put simply: keywords are researched and handed over. Writers produce paragraphs and work the keywords in. For a long time, this way of working was rewarded with SEO traffic. Articles like that win rankings less and less often now. At the same time, ChatGPT as a text engine can produce exactly this kind of content at zero cost. That no longer gives you a competitive edge. The process has reached its end. The question is what new ways of working look like.

Traffic wins are getting harder to predict

SEO as a channel has become more volatile and more complex, as have all online marketing channels, for that matter. Google core updates cause fluctuations. User signals such as clicks and views are ranking factors. 75 percent of traffic keywords are unknown. On top of that, competition is strong. In every industry we often see a handful of players who are visible for practically every keyword. Over all of this sits the question of whether Google will roll out its AI Overviews more widely. Then queries in position 1 get answered by an AI. If you offer the same thing, you will have a hard time. So you need new strategies for relevant content that holds its own in this environment.

First Hand Experience in topic development

So how can you systematically meet the requirement to factor “First Hand Experience” into your topics every time? The graphic shows our approach. On the one hand, the approach starts from the benefit for the user: what do they get out of consuming the content? On the other, it is about connecting that with real experience and expertise.

We talk through examples in our podcast. One example from our field: the “SEO relaunch checklist”. There are countless generic articles on this topic. We chose to show and discuss the personal SEO relaunch checklist of an experienced SEO manager from a corporation. The SEO manager used her checklist for herself and for internal communication.

In our scheme it is “action driven content”, because it supports concrete actions, combined with an interview with an expert.

The results: better content performance

Better user signals

The Google leak on user signals showed, at the latest: in the end, the top 3 rankings show whether the content lands with users. First Hand Experience content keeps users, because it puts the experience and expertise of real people at the center.

Relevant SEO traffic

If you rely on First Hand Experience, you have a new approach of your own for SEO. It is a very specific, qualified way of addressing your users. You are more resistant to Google updates. And you have your own strategy against the flood of AI in the search results.

Broader performance

If you rely on First Hand Experience, you leave “SEO content” behind. These are pieces that work on every channel. The content drives high click rates in newsletters, generates LinkedIn impressions, and qualified leads as well.

… and AI-ready in the future

AI in the processes

To be clear: this is not a farewell to AI development. AI tools can be used for a whole range of process steps. For example: brainstorming ideas, developing questions for an interview, developing headlines for a blog article, proofreading, editing.

... but not as the end product

But the approach is not: “We use ChatGPT to produce paragraphs or answer questions, then plant them one to one into our blog articles.” Any AI system can do that itself. You cannot outperform your competitors or ChatGPT if you do exactly the same thing.

How long did this article take?

I looked at the clock ;-) This article, too, was created on the “First Hand Experience” principle. How long it took us, what the process looks like, what it delivers, and how you can put it to work in your company: we can talk all of that through.

For marketing teams we develop individual content performance programs. In our Academy we also offer workshops on topics such as First Hand Experience.

Deepen your SEO knowledge: every Monday by email

GEO SEO newsletter

Inspiring conversations with professionals from the industry

How Südwestrundfunk (SWR) works on search experience: interview with Sarah Stein

SEO for software companies: interview with Lisa Karasch

How the SaaS startup awork builds its SEO visibility: interview with Ayla Grzegowski

Landing pages for software companies: interview with Thomas Kemp

What does an online shop need to rank successfully? Interview with Stefan Vorwerk

How Hansgrohe does SEO in 40 countries: interview with Jörg Niethammer

Hubspot's SEO strategy: interview with Jenny Lapp

How user testing works: interview with Astrid Kramer on UX and SEO

Topics