June 8, 2026Benjamin O’Daniel
Analyses with AI: How Good Are the Recommendations?
We now see it in practically every engagement: marketing teams create analyses with the help of AI, including concrete recommendations on what they should change on their website. Which approaches do we see in the market? How is the quality of the AI analyses? How can you work with them, as a marketing lead, and also as an expert?
We discuss all of that in the current podcast episode. This much up front: practically everyone in charge has mixed feelings. Everyone wants to use the new opportunities. At the same time, many are uncertain, watchful, and sometimes also annoyed by the AI hype.

Approaches: this is how AI analyses are created
Manual AI analyses
Manual AI analyses often follow a multi-step process. For example, criteria are worked out with ChatGPT, such as “Name proven measures for more AI visibility”. Then you enter your own website and ask for a review. You follow up several times, asking for measures to be derived. The result: for zero euros in cost, you immediately have an individual analysis. That is fundamentally new compared with the time before AI. Back then, the only options were training or consulting.
Feeding AI with data
At a more advanced level, various data providers are connected to AI systems. For example Google Search Console, or SEO tools and GEO tools. Claude then has a concrete data set it can work on. After that, concrete work orders are assigned. In the results, we tend to see clearly better quality here. Even so, it is not clear whether, and in what depth, the data was actually analyzed. Errors keep showing up. For the recommendations, the systems often fall back on general world knowledge.
Building AI tools
The next logical step is to develop your own tools with AI. For example, to create or review content against certain criteria. Or to monitor certain prompts. The possibilities are endless. At the same time, the question here too is whether this is really the lever in the end. Even if such new tools are up and running very quickly thanks to vibe coding, they also have to prove themselves over time. Fabian Jaeckert has developed several AI tools for us, including an AI log file analysis, a Prompt Research Tool and an AI Visibility Tool. As so often, the devil is in the detail.
How AI systems behave, and how people do
AI systems are very often opinionated, with generalizing judgments. “Your website has no visibility” or “In your field, you are invisible.” That is combined with concrete help: “With these measures you will turn things around” or “Calculation: this is how you get 50 new leads per month”. AI systems master classic storytelling. If you point out methodological weaknesses or exaggerated promises of success, the AI gives in immediately. The quick about-face is a familiar pattern. When asked, the system also points out weaknesses in the analysis. But only when asked specifically, not proactively. At the same time, we can also say this: there are, again and again, good recommendations that the AI makes.
On the human side, we see mixed feelings. A lot of enthusiasm, because everyone is open-minded. But also doubt and uncertainty. AI systems can be very convincing. AI analyses are often run in areas where the company itself has no experts. In our case, these are SEO and GEO analyses on AI visibility. That makes the AI system, from the outset, the (supposedly) smartest participant in the group. At the same time, we also see that the people in charge hesitate when it comes to implementing the AI recommendations. Someone has to take responsibility. Nobody wants to invest days or weeks of working time in something where, in the end, it is still unclear whether it is the right approach. If in doubt, the AI apologizes once, and that is it.
Our assessment
It is the new reality that marketing departments get help from AI systems. You want to move something and start with something. That is a good thing. But especially on strategic topics, audits, analyses, and measures, you should work with absolute care. If mistakes are made here, or important things are overlooked, that runs through the entire implementation. In the end, simply less comes out of it.
AI analyses and recommendations should always be checked and also questioned critically. We are big fans of bringing AI in more strongly at a later point. For example, once the strategy, the measures, and the templates have already been worked out, and you want to be more efficient in the implementation.
We also see AI fatigue, a sense of overkill. Nobody can be enthusiastic about AI 24/7. Yes, a lot is possible. But that can also distract from the actual work. In our consulting, we are happy to look at AI analyses and give personal feedback on them.

Our conversations with SEO and GEO professionals

How SEO writers work with ChatGPT: interview with Monika Weber

How the SaaS startup awork builds its SEO visibility: interview with Ayla Grzegowski

How does an AI system talk about your company? Interview with Hanns Kronenberg
We advise marketing managers on SEO and GEO
For anyone seeking an SEO sparring partner or comprehensive SEO consulting, Fabian and Benjamin are the perfect choice. As an in-house SEO expert, I sought competent SEO support and found it with them. During a very pleasant introductory meeting, we jointly developed an approach to establish SEO among the individual stakeholders and thereby gain more internal visibility for the subject. Based on this initial discussion and a joint kick-off with the stakeholders, they developed a sound SEO and content strategy for a product area. Since then, they have both supported me as sparring partners during implementation.
The collaboration with Fabian and Benjamin is a great pleasure for me and all project participants, as they are masters of their craft and bring immense passion for SEO. This combination is infectious and motivates everyone to achieve peak performance.
Regina BiskopDeutsche Kreditbank AG
I look back with great satisfaction on the SEO project that we carried out with Benjamin and Fabian. Firstly, the collaboration was on a very pleasant, goal-oriented level. Secondly, the consultation was structured in such a way that we could immediately start with the implementation. We received very concrete optimization suggestions that were tailored to our internal capacities and therefore realistically implementable. Even though only a few months have passed, we can already see the first results of our work in the Google rankings. Traffic for our relevant keywords is steadily increasing, and we still have enough concrete work packages from Benjamin in the pipeline to boost our site. Furthermore, through the consultation, we have acquired so much internal SEO know-how that we can now optimize our site independently. And most importantly: Visitor numbers have doubled – with correspondingly positive effects on sales.
Mark MaudererDigital Marketing Manager, Bierbaum Proenen











